Yeah one thing I’ve noticed with these sorts of ‘All in one’ weapons, similar to that one that allows sorceries and incants, is that their drawback versatility is just abysmal scaling
dagmarcascade313 months ago
They're so afraid of making these types of weapon strong, that mediocre weapons out scale them by just existing, its insane.
E
ethan.santos3 months ago
Weapon catalysts should've been an entire category
H
hakanhenk7473 months ago
If Carian Sorcery Sword has a million fans, then I'm one of them. If Carian Sorcery Sword has one fan, then I'm THAT ONE. If Carian Sorcery Sword has no fans, that means I'm dead. (the invader killed me)😤
G
garytaylor193 months ago
It may be bad, but it's cool, and that's reason enough for me to make a build around it.
L
luz_mireles3 months ago
I'm still gonna run weapons like that. They're extremely unique, so I'm gonna have fun. I'm in that stage of Elden Ring where I'm just making my own builds and combinations with stuff no one uses. Even Crystal Knife can be used well in a Dual Dagger Build.
G
georgesnight773 months ago
My poor Blue Flame what did they do to you? 😂
R
robertyadav6863 months ago
In my opinion the catalyst should had been the AOW
M
manyadaylight53 months ago
I honestly feel like they had big plans for these gimmick weapons but and this when the tinfoil hat comes on I feel like Bandai namco was really pushing them to just release it the way it was
D
dimitrios_bonbach3 months ago
It doesn't even have the mechanic that the ds3 catalyst/weapons have, where you can almost seamlessly mix spells with melee
L
luce.antoine3 months ago
What it lacks in power it makes up in style and being cool. Put a Maine Gauche with parry in the off hand and mix up the parries, powerstance attacks and Carian Slicers and you'll be the coolest spellblade out there
M
meghana_bobal3 months ago
I remember right after the dlc dropped they buffed the int scaling to S because the spell damage sucked and IT STILL SUCKED, yet no more buffs :(
joshuachen2823 months ago
Jack of all trades, master of none case
R
robert.maldonado2 months, 4 weeks ago
Hot take: The Carian Knight's sword should have been able to cast spells with it's heavy.
G
genaro.chavarría3 months ago
I will say ds2 had the best weapon catalysts
angela.patterson3 months ago
They'll never match your power, crystal weapon blue flame <\3
agathe_marion2 months, 3 weeks ago
Fromsoft has a long history of having cool concepts and just purposefully making them really bad.
M
melissa_haynes3 months ago
there was a weapon like this in dark souls 2 and you could infuse it and buff it with magic and it hit like a drunk stepdad. i think they should buff it to be actually good but i doubt they ever will.
R
robert_richardson2 months, 4 weeks ago
El repentino español me ha dejado un rato reiniciando el cerebro 🤣
![[FIL] Team Yandex vs Nigma Galaxy (BO3) | The International 15 2026 Playoffs Day 2](https://i.ytimg.com/vi/nK41cYkkTwk/maxresdefault.jpg)
Yeah one thing I’ve noticed with these sorts of ‘All in one’ weapons, similar to that one that allows sorceries and incants, is that their drawback versatility is just abysmal scaling
They're so afraid of making these types of weapon strong, that mediocre weapons out scale them by just existing, its insane.
Weapon catalysts should've been an entire category
If Carian Sorcery Sword has a million fans, then I'm one of them. If Carian Sorcery Sword has one fan, then I'm THAT ONE. If Carian Sorcery Sword has no fans, that means I'm dead. (the invader killed me)😤
It may be bad, but it's cool, and that's reason enough for me to make a build around it.
I'm still gonna run weapons like that. They're extremely unique, so I'm gonna have fun. I'm in that stage of Elden Ring where I'm just making my own builds and combinations with stuff no one uses. Even Crystal Knife can be used well in a Dual Dagger Build.
My poor Blue Flame what did they do to you? 😂
In my opinion the catalyst should had been the AOW
I honestly feel like they had big plans for these gimmick weapons but and this when the tinfoil hat comes on I feel like Bandai namco was really pushing them to just release it the way it was
It doesn't even have the mechanic that the ds3 catalyst/weapons have, where you can almost seamlessly mix spells with melee
What it lacks in power it makes up in style and being cool. Put a Maine Gauche with parry in the off hand and mix up the parries, powerstance attacks and Carian Slicers and you'll be the coolest spellblade out there
I remember right after the dlc dropped they buffed the int scaling to S because the spell damage sucked and IT STILL SUCKED, yet no more buffs :(
Jack of all trades, master of none case
Hot take: The Carian Knight's sword should have been able to cast spells with it's heavy.
I will say ds2 had the best weapon catalysts
They'll never match your power, crystal weapon blue flame <\3
Fromsoft has a long history of having cool concepts and just purposefully making them really bad.
there was a weapon like this in dark souls 2 and you could infuse it and buff it with magic and it hit like a drunk stepdad. i think they should buff it to be actually good but i doubt they ever will.
El repentino español me ha dejado un rato reiniciando el cerebro 🤣
Quincy ahh sword